Zeteo UK

Zeteo UK

The UK’s Terror Watchdog Wanted to Ban Palestine Demos. We Investigated His Israel Connections

Jonathan Hall KC has been the UK’s independent reviewer of terrorism legislation since 2019 and has overseen a crackdown on the right to protest. How independent is he really? Owen Jones investigates.

Owen Jones's avatar
Owen Jones
Nov 19, 2026
∙ Paid

Thank you for subscribing to Zeteo UK. If you are currently a free subscriber, please do become a paid subscriber today so you can read and watch all of our Zeteo UK original content without hitting a paywall – and also so you can help fund independent journalism in Britain. – Mehdi Hasan

Johnathan Hall KC, on ‘Newsnight’ in January 2026. Photo: BBC.

Earlier this year, Human Rights Watch published a report entitled “Silencing the Streets: The Right to Protest Under Attack in the United Kingdom”. Successive governments, they argued, had expanded police powers, criminalised protest tactics and restricted peaceful dissent, all ultimately risking “fraying the fabric of democracy itself”. Our rights and freedoms, secured at huge cost and sacrifice by our ancestors, have been tossed on to a bonfire.

Just how did we get here? The assault on Britain’s hard-won civil liberties has been a bipartisan affair, with Labour and Conservative governments alike restricting protests and deploying counterterrorism legislation against domestic political activism. Indeed, just this week, the UN Human Rights Committee warned against the misuse of counterterrorism laws to suppress peaceful activism, stressing that freedom of association extends even to activities deemed controversial, dissenting or disruptive.

Yet there has been little scrutiny of the lawyer tasked with independently reviewing terrorism legislation.

Meet Jonathan Hall KC, Britain’s independent reviewer of terrorism legislation for more than seven years. Appointing him in May 2019, Conservative then-Home Secretary Sajid Javid announced that “it is vital we have robust oversight to ensure our counter-terrorism laws are fair, necessary and proportionate”.

Now, as Hall’s tenure draws to a close, Labour Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has lauded his “rigorous oversight and analysis”, claiming they “improved our laws and made our country safer”.

But Hall’s record raises serious questions about his independence and impartiality, particularly when it comes to Palestine.

He has called for a ban on pro-Palestinian demonstrations, defended the proscription of Palestine Action and accused human rights organisations of tolerating violence because people had their brains “scrambled by Gaza”.

An investigation by Zeteo UK has uncovered further details of his dealings with Israeli organisations.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Zeteo UK · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.